RSS and Atom feed icon News feeds

Liberating Geopolitical Borders

  • Di-Ann Eisnor, Chris Goad, Anselm Hook, Platial.com, 5035604608, diann@platial.comMap Single City Skyline: Please see Appendix

Introduction

Platial is the user-created online atlas. We aspire to bridge people, neighborhoods and nations through everyone’s Places and maps. Platial is a free resource for everyone everywhere to save and share Places that are meaningful to them and to discover Places we always wished existed in our towns and around the world. Platial launched in December 2005 and now has 6000 people world-wide sharing and discovering 200,000 Places and 2500 maps related to adventure, history, politics, music, architecture, romance, and mapping their own lives and travels.

By enabling people anywhere to annotate Places and create maps, shifts in connection and territory become visible. A new social territory becomes evident which is an alternative to the nationalism of borders. When geography can be viewed through the eyes of many, geopolitical boundaries may begin to melt.

We have analyzed a very early, limited data set to show a picture of a potentially post geo-political world and the technology required to support it.

Map showing all the Platial places as of April 15, 2006.

Examples

The following are examples of the kinds aggregations of Places people are creating on Platial (maps, event calendars, guides, stories built from places):

Autobiogeography

Half of all people who add Places to Platial create autobiogeographies, which tell the stories of their lives through the Places they’ve lived, worked, and travelled.

My Life by mydogischelsea

Local Guides

The next most common use of the platform is people acting as local guides, mapping their favorite restaurants, bars, parks, or anything else they might share with an out-of-town guest or with local friends.

My NY by edshepp

History

Our users have compiled the beginning of a historic archive, which spans local history (Ottawa in the 1800s), world events (Where I was When 9/11 Happened, Important Protests), World History (Women Who Changed the World), Ancient History (7 Wonders of the Ancient World).

Women Who Changed the World by Tracy_The_Astonishing

Activism

Maps related to general activism are significant; toxic locations, biodiesel and alternative fuel stations, fair trade, reuse, and biking are prevalent. See our list at http://platial.typepad.com/news/2006/03/here_is_a_compi.html for quick reference.

Public Biodiesel Stations

Interests:

Birding, crafting, hiking, walking, eating, trucker slang, roller derbies, punk rock venues and mystery spots… These are just a few of the different topics around which users have created maps.

Birding in Singapore by kclama

Architecture:

A compilation of modernism, architecture found on Platial.

Travels

The function of a geo-based travel journal has given people an easy way to track where they’ve been and where they want to go.

Places I’ve Travelled

MarghalFreeman’s 20 hours to Budapest

Love, Romance and Heartbreak

This deserves it’s own section since hundreds of people are sharing their stories of love lost and found.

Hopeless Romantic Paiges

Early Data Collection

The following list is the raw material for the new kind of atlas we’re trying to enable (one not dominated by traditional geopolitics/traditional borders). Data collected is based on 4 months of tracking with limited usage and worldwide representation. It accounts for approximately 212 cities where at least 1 Place was added.

Data sources:

  • Places and Place distribution throughout the globe

  • Places per city

  • Users per city

  • Tags per city

  • Places per User

  • Regions with high concentration of Place counts within 1/2 degree lat/long of centers of 212 major cities (Excludes Places added by commercial sources listed as “system” data on Platial).

Analysis methodology:

  • Correlating cities based on tags

  • Correlating cities based on users

  • Similar cities based on tag overlap

  • Comparison of top 10 cities by #users, #tags, # Places

Benchmarks/assumptions:

The following are assumptions based on limited data. Portland is the origin of Platial giving it an inflated activity. Over time the true activity of Portland will emerge and members will be more geographically dispersed. The benchmarks show some of the formats used to collect and view data over time.

Sister-cities exist. This can be exposed by revealing a social topography irrelevant to proximity or national borders.

Portland and NY correlate more than Portland and Vancouver BC.

New York and Toronto correlate more then Toronto and Vancouver BC.

Some cities are gateways to many other cities

New York and Boston have high correlation to several other cities *.

Of the 10 Most Active Cities, Toronto has the lowest correlation to other cities.

* Portland is excluded from this count due to Platial being headquartered here.

Correlation of 10 Most Active Cities Based On Overlapping Tags (Top 20 per city)

10

NY/Boston

5

SF/BC

9

Portlan/NY

5

LA/Boston

7

Portland/Boston

5

LA/Seattle

7

Chicago/SF

5

BC/Chicago

7

Seattle/Boston

4

London/BC

6

Portland/ SF

3

Portland/London

6

Portland/Seattle

3

Portland/BC

6

Portland/Chicago

3

NY/London

6

NY/LA

3

London/Boston

6

NY/Seattle

3

London/Seattle

6

NY/Chicago

3

London/Chicago

6

SF/LA

3

London/SF

6

SF/Boston

3

London/LA

6

Seattle/Boston

3

Toronto/Boston

6

LA/Chicago

3

LA/BC

6

Seattle/Toronto

2

London/Toronto

5

Portland/Toronto

2

Toronto/Seattle

5

Portland/LA

2

Toronto/BC

5

NY/SF

2

Toronto/Chicago

5

NY/Toronto

1

Toronto/SF

5

NY/Vancouver BC

1

Toronto/LA

Coffee, restaurant(s), city orientation and food unite across borders:

10/10 most active cities have their city name in their Top 20 tags.

9/10 most active cities list coffee in their Top 20 tags.

9/10 most active cities list restaurant(s).

8/10 most active cities list food.

Art and home also rank high across the board.

Unique features of each city still stand out:

Portland lists street art, graffiti and DIY in top 20 tags.

London lists sculpture, bars, and architecture in their Top 20.

Music, bus tickets, and mailing services are unique to Chicago’s Top 20.

Top 20 Overall Tags For 10 Most Active Cities

615

coffee

514

fairtrade

380

restaurant(s)

202

kitsalano

190

food

180

portland

175

kids

124

art

117

scav

113

tea

101

fun

84

park

83

london

79

guy2k

74

street art

73

free

70

Los angeles

67

toronto

57

san francisco

Citizens are charting a collective course throughout the world, which can begin to be articulated and which reduces the importance of national borders.

Shenzhen has more Places than Memphis.

Visualization of a universal city skyline where each city represents one building.

Maps could be used to increase ties with people in isolated lands (providing internet access and good base map technology).

Melbourne, Bangalore, Helsinki, Taipei, Milan, Osaka, and Tokyo all have the same exact representation.

Platial place counts within 1/2 degree lat/long of centers of major cities 
 (Excludes system places)

1 Portland 2026

54 Prague 24

107 Delhi 4

160 Dalian 1

2 New York 1458

55 Sydney 24

108 Casablanca 4

161 Taichung 1

3 San Francisco 1133

56 Brussels 23

109 Santiago 4

162 Hangzhou 1

4 Los Angeles 996

57 Singapore 21

110 Baghdad 3

163 Bamako 1

5 Boston 674

58 Vienna 18

111 Shanghai 3

164 Dakar 1

6 Toronto 565

59 Juárez 17

112 Bilbao 3

165 Vitória 1

7 Seattle 481

60 Copenhagen 17

113 İzmir 3

166 Quito 1

8 Vancouver 481

61 Leeds 17

114 Tianjin 3

167 Goiânia 1

9 Chicago 425

62 Kōbe 16

115 Karaj 3

168 La Paz 1

10 London 306

63 Glasgow 16

116 Nairobi 3

169 Hamamatsu 1

11 Philadelphia 360

64 Inchŏn 15

117 Alexandria 3

170 Adelaide 1

12 San Diego 282

65 Mexico City 15

118 Kuala Lumpur 3

171 Barquisimeto 1

13 Atlanta 258

66 Madrid 14

119 Kiev 3

172 Santo Domingo 1

14 Austin 218

67 Calgary 13

120 Guatemala 3

173 Bucaramanga 1

15 Denver 218

68 Tel Aviv-Yafo 13

121 Hamburg 3

174 Caracas 1

16 Houston 202

69 Berlin 13

122 Lyon 3

175 Okayama 1

17 Phoenix 184

70 Munich 12

123 Nezahualcóyotl 3

176 Maracaibo 1

18 Cleveland 137

71 Gizeh 12

124 Lima 3

177 Monterrey 1

19 Miami 133

72 Moscow 12

125 Porto 3

178 Porto Alegre 1

20 Dallas 130

73 Barcelona 11

126 Bombay 2

179 Kyōto 1

21 Nashville 123

74 Peking 10

127 Dubai 2

180 Medellín 1

22 Sacramento 115

75 Melbourne 10

128 Phnum Pénh 2

181 Guangzhou 1

23 Yokohama 111

76 Bangalore 10

129 Taejŏn 2

182 Nāgpur 1

24 Cincinnati 107

77 Helsinki 10

130 Fukuoka 2

183 Āgra 1

25 Las Vegas 104

78 Taipei 10

131 Perth 2

184 Jabalpur 1

26 Saint Louis 101

79 Milan 10

132 Kaohsiung 2

185 Johannesburg 1

27 Raleigh 98

80 Osaka 10

133 Manila 2

186 Port Elizabeth 1

28 Milwaukee 94

81 Tōkyō 10

134 Yogyakarta 2

187 Kathmandu 1

29 Kansas City 92

82 San Juan 9

135 Hiroshima 2

188 Harare 1

30 Pittsburgh 92

83 Buenos Aires 9

136 Hāora 2

189 Kochi 1

31 Orlando 87

84 Sapporo 9

137 Dhāka 2

190 Damascus 1

32 Montreal 76

85 Cape Town 9

138 Ha Noi 2

191 Ahmadābād 1

33 Columbus 74

86 Nova Iguaçu 9

139 Ho Chi Minh City 2

192 Nāshik 1

34 Rome 70

87 Stockholm 9

140 Novosibirsk 2

193 Lahore 1

35 Ottawa 67

88 Sheffield 8

141 Soweto 2

194 Jaipur 1

36 New Orleans 66

89 Budapest 8

142 Belgrade 2

195 Aurangābād 1

37 Oklahoma City 66

90 Auckland 8

143 Sevilla 2

196 Mandalay 1

38 Paris 63

91 Nagoya 7

144 Bucharest 2

197 Rangoon 1

39 Tampa 59

92 Bangkok 7

145 Dresden 2

198 Luoyang 1

40 Jacksonville 59

93 Shizuoka 7

146 Luanda 2

199 Semarang 1

41 Indianapolis 59

94 Panamá 7

147 Stuttgart 2

200 al-Mawşil 1

42 Saitama 57

95 Brisbane 6

148 São Paulo 2

201 Bielefeld 1

43 Shenzhen 54

96 Sendai 6

149 Campinas 2

202 Córdoba 1

44 San Antonio 50

97 İstanbul 6

150 Durban 2

203 Cartagena 1

45 Fresno 49

98 Bremen 6

151 Montevideo 2

204 Xianyang 1

46 Louisville 47

99 Bayrūt 6

152 ʿAmmān 2

205 Hai Phong 1

47 Greensboro 45

100 Ankara 5

153 León 2

206 Brazzaville 1

48 Charlotte 43

101 San José 5

154 Mecca 2

207 Warsaw 1

49 Dublin 41

102 Recife 5

155 Managua 2

208 Lanzhou 1

50 Memphis 39

103 Marseille 5

156 Havanna 2

209 Chongqing 1

51 Rochester 37

104 Pusan 5

157 Brasília 1

210 Tangerang 1

52 Amsterdam

105 Madras 5

158 Belo Horizonte 1

211 Tijuana 1

53 Birmingham 34

106 Saint Petersburg 4

159 Ningbo 1

212 Bouaké 1

Technology

Platial aims to contribute to an ecology of shared geodata, not to build an isolated platform. This aim has guided the design of our georepository and API. The elements of our technology are: 1) A repository architecture that supports user contribution of data types, not just data; 2) an API that enables federation of repositories ; 3) our own running repository (of course); 4) GeoRSS feeds, and 5) A carefully engineered user interface for the web public. Here are some details.

Repository Architecture

At the core of the repository design is a set of geolocated items. The notion of an item is open-ended, and users of the API (and in future the GUI) can define their own types of items. The item class hierarchy is seeded with three basic types: places, events, and posts (a "post" consists of user commentary about a place or event, and resembles a blog post). Additional item types are defined by specifying property sheets. This will enable characterization by users of the kinds of geolocated things that interest them: bird sightings, surf spots, historical buildings, etcetera. Google Base is the most prominent current example of this general approach to open data types, but not the most recent. We employ the more easily aggregated and earlier RDF formulation: our item types are definable as an RDF/OWL class.

The use of the comparatively free-wheeling RDF data formalism is fundamental to extensibility, and differentiates our approach from the RDBMS data model that underpins conventional GIS. However, motivated by performance considerations, our implementation is a hybrid. In effect we bolt an RDF triple store for item property sheets onto a more traditional framework for static aspects of the data design.

The repository also contains aggregates of items - things that correspond roughly to GIS layers, except that they impose fewer type constraints on members. From the user's perspective, some aggregates are built explicitly by adding items to "maps," and others implicitly by queries or tagging. Other varieties of supporting data are present as well , representing such things as user accounts, buddy lists, and grievances.

API

The API provides web access to repository contents. Like the repository itself, it is formulated in RDF terms: a call to the API is an RDF object representing a method application. A choice of XML and JSON syntax is available. Calls in the XML syntax generally resemble XML-RPC; the JSON syntax is simpler and more concise.

The API uses URIs rather than simple identifiers in naming. For example, names of items in the Platial repository have the form http://platial.com/rdf/item/1234. A consequence is that content can be aggregated from multiple repositories using the API (and our licensing terms do not restrict use of the API by others).

GeoRSS feeds

The notion of tagging RSS items with geographic locations has been around since at least 2002 (blogmapper exploited this idea). In current practice, two variants of geotagging of RSS items have reasonably widespread adoption or mindshare: one relies on the W3C geo vocabulary (http://www.w3.org/2003/01/geo/), with tags geo:lat, geo:long, geo:alt, and the other, more recent development, is the http://georss.org/ initiative, which covers more cases (such as tagging items with lines and polygons as well as points). Platial provides the latter variety of feed over common filters on its data (e.g. by contributor and bounding box, or by map).

Future directions

Platial's future technological work will concentrate on adding to the expressiveness of representations in the repository and on adding conduits for inward and outward flows of geodata. Whenever possible, tools enabling others to add their own representations and conduits will be preferred. For example, we are now adding geo-aggregators to our tool kit, which will support population of the Platial repository by anyone willing to generate an RSS feed.

There are numerous possibilities for employing customized representations of Place to anchor new channels of communication between people. Communities sharing interests relating to social, ecological, and cultural topics can benefit by building their own representations of the aspects of Place that concern them.

The traditional world of GIS still limits the forms of user contribution for people outside of the GIS guilds to stereotyped activity: database schemas control the form of data, and the expert insiders control the schemas.

Earlier outline notes:

  • Aggregation and distribution of data

  • Further looks at social border opening and public availability of findings at http://www.peoplesatlas.org/